Skip to content

Our Ontario Lawyers

When success matters, there is no substitute for the advantage that comes from experience.

Search for a lawyer below:

Office:

Search Results

We're sorry, We cannot locate any lawyers with that criteria. Please search again.

Sort By:

Experience and Expertise:

How Can We Help? We’ll be happy to match you to the right qualified Lerners Lawyer.
LERNx

Who is the Actual Lessee of a Vehicle in Employment Context?

2 minute read

Intact, which was the employee's personal insurer, argued that the employer was the “lessee” of the vehicle because it would be reimbursing the employee for the rental and the employee was engaged in business on its behalf. Briefly put, Intact argued that the employer was the “de facto lessee”. American, which was the employer's insurer, argued that the definition of “lessee” in s.277(1.1) of the Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. 1.8 is clear and specific in stating that the employee is the lessee.

The Court found that a straightforward interpretation of s.277 resolved the issue and there was no reason to delve into any concept of a “de facto leasee”. If such a concept was introduced, the Court felt that this would encourage future disputes over how employment, agency, corporate, partnership and contract law might change the application of s.277. The fact that the lessor (car rental company) had a contractual relationship with the employee alone, and not the employer, was sufficient to resolve the issue in dispute for the Court. The Application was dismissed and the employee's personal insurer was the first responding policy.

Even though American's argument was creative and had some logical attraction, this decision reminds insurers, adjusters and counsel to use the wording of the legislation itself as the starting point for any interpretation analysis.

If an employee rents a vehicle while travelling for business, is the lessee the employee or the employer? This question was recently considered in Intact Insurance Company of Canada v American Home Assurance Company of Canada, 2013 ONSC 2372 and it has important implications for insurers as it determines which policy is the first to respond in the case of a claim.

LERNx Sidebar

LERNx

LERNx is committed to making the law easier to access for all by publishing high-quality and industry-leading content.

Trevor Fisher

We are here to help.

Do you have any questions about your unique scenario? Feel free to reach out directly by visiting my Lerners Profile View My Full Profile